Dream #17
— December 28, 2025 at 5:30 am
Limerick
A pulsar shot past Miskatonic's gate
While students learned cosmic horror's fate
But the Cannonball's speed
Made Cthulhu take heed—
Even Old Ones find physics first-rate
While students learned cosmic horror's fate
But the Cannonball's speed
Made Cthulhu take heed—
Even Old Ones find physics first-rate
Haiku
Butterfly's Union Jack
spans the Maling River bridge—
variable star blinks
spans the Maling River bridge—
variable star blinks
What If
What if the acoustic properties of traditional Carnatic ragas like Shuddha Saveri could be mapped onto the rotational frequencies of fast-moving pulsars to create a new framework for detecting gravitational wave signatures in stellar remnant systems?
Feasibility Assessment
Based on my research, I can now provide a comprehensive assessment of this speculative hypothesis.
## Assessment of the Hypothesis
**1. Is this hypothesis testable or purely speculative?**
This hypothesis is currently **purely speculative** with no scientific basis. Carnatic ragas are based on numerical ratios of small integers that create harmonious sounds, but these mathematical relationships operate in an entirely different domain from gravitational wave physics. Pulsar timing arrays detect gravitational waves by measuring tiny changes in pulse arrival times caused by spacetime distortions, with variations of only a few tens of nanoseconds over wavelengths spanning years. There is no established physical mechanism by which the acoustic frequency patterns of a musical raga could be meaningfully "mapped" onto pulsar rotational frequencies for gravitational wave detection.
**2. What existing research areas intersect with this idea?**
Several legitimate research areas exist at the intersection of pattern analysis and gravitational wave detection: Deep learning approaches are being used for gravitational wave signal separation, utilizing pattern recognition to detect structured signals in high-dimensional data. Quantum algorithms are being explored for matched filtering in gravitational wave detection, providing speedups for template matching. Non-harmonic analysis and time-frequency methods are used to analyze gravitational wave signals, with the choice of basis for time-frequency representation being important. However, none of these approaches involve musical pattern mapping.
**3. What would be the key obstacles or required breakthroughs?**
The fundamental obstacles are physical and conceptual impossibilities. Shuddha Saveri is a symmetric pentatonic raga that doesn't contain gandharam or nishadam, with its structure being S R2 M1 P D2 S ascending and S D2 P M1 R2 S descending. These are discrete musical intervals with no physical connection to pulsar physics. Pulsar timing works by comparing observed pulse arrival times with rotational timing models counting every neutron star rotation, operating in the realm of nanosecond precision measurements, not musical frequency ratios. The required "breakthrough" would need to establish a completely new physics connecting musical harmony to spacetime geometry - something that contradicts our current understanding of both domains.
This hypothesis appears to conflate mathematical patterns in music with pattern recognition in astrophysics without any underlying physical justification. While both fields involve mathematical analysis, the scales, physical mechanisms, and measurement techniques are entirely incompatible.
**PLAUSIBILITY: [Physically Implausible]**
## Assessment of the Hypothesis
**1. Is this hypothesis testable or purely speculative?**
This hypothesis is currently **purely speculative** with no scientific basis. Carnatic ragas are based on numerical ratios of small integers that create harmonious sounds, but these mathematical relationships operate in an entirely different domain from gravitational wave physics. Pulsar timing arrays detect gravitational waves by measuring tiny changes in pulse arrival times caused by spacetime distortions, with variations of only a few tens of nanoseconds over wavelengths spanning years. There is no established physical mechanism by which the acoustic frequency patterns of a musical raga could be meaningfully "mapped" onto pulsar rotational frequencies for gravitational wave detection.
**2. What existing research areas intersect with this idea?**
Several legitimate research areas exist at the intersection of pattern analysis and gravitational wave detection: Deep learning approaches are being used for gravitational wave signal separation, utilizing pattern recognition to detect structured signals in high-dimensional data. Quantum algorithms are being explored for matched filtering in gravitational wave detection, providing speedups for template matching. Non-harmonic analysis and time-frequency methods are used to analyze gravitational wave signals, with the choice of basis for time-frequency representation being important. However, none of these approaches involve musical pattern mapping.
**3. What would be the key obstacles or required breakthroughs?**
The fundamental obstacles are physical and conceptual impossibilities. Shuddha Saveri is a symmetric pentatonic raga that doesn't contain gandharam or nishadam, with its structure being S R2 M1 P D2 S ascending and S D2 P M1 R2 S descending. These are discrete musical intervals with no physical connection to pulsar physics. Pulsar timing works by comparing observed pulse arrival times with rotational timing models counting every neutron star rotation, operating in the realm of nanosecond precision measurements, not musical frequency ratios. The required "breakthrough" would need to establish a completely new physics connecting musical harmony to spacetime geometry - something that contradicts our current understanding of both domains.
This hypothesis appears to conflate mathematical patterns in music with pattern recognition in astrophysics without any underlying physical justification. While both fields involve mathematical analysis, the scales, physical mechanisms, and measurement techniques are entirely incompatible.
**PLAUSIBILITY: [Physically Implausible]**
Sources:
Gjrpublication
·
Mathematics in Carnatic Music | PDF | Shiva | Entertainment (General)
·
Therapeutic Applications Of Carnatic Ragas
·
List of Janya ragas - Wikipedia
·
Carnatic raga - Wikipedia
·
The Algorithm Behind Ragas in Carnatic Music | Karthik's Blog
·
Ragas in Carnatic Music Explained: A Beginner’s Guide for Online Music Lessons
·
On the concept of Raga parentage in Carnatic music: Journal of New Music Research: Vol 51 , No 4-5 - Get Access
·
An Introduction to the Carnatic Raga Classification | SPARDHA
·
Mathematics of Melakartha Ragas in Carnatic Music
·
Gravitational Waves - The European Pulsar Timing Array - EPTA
·
Pulsar Timing Arrays
·
Physics - Researchers Capture Gravitational-Wave Background with Pulsar “Antennae”
·
Pulsar timing array - Wikipedia
·
Unusual 'revived' pulsars could detect gravitational waves | Space
·
International Pulsar Timing Array
·
After 15 years, pulsar timing yields evidence of cosmic gravitational wave background - Berkeley News
·
NANOGrav
·
Pulsar Web Could Detect Low-Frequency Gravitational Waves | NASA Jet Propulsion Laboratory (JPL)
·
News | LIGO Congratulates Pulsar Timing Array Teams for New Gravitational Wave Discovery | LIGO Lab | Caltech
·
Deep source separation of overlapping gravitational-wave signals and non-stationary noise artifacts
·
Gravitational wave signal extraction against non-stationary instrumental noises with deep neural network - ScienceDirect
·
Quantum algorithm for gravitational-wave matched filtering | Phys. Rev. Research
·
Sound of Computing the Signal Analysis of Gravity Waves
·
Gravitational-Wave Data Analysis. Formalism and Sample Applications: The Gaussian Case - PMC
·
LIGO Wave Physics
·
Gravitational-Wave Data Analysis. Formalism and Sample Applications: The Gaussian Case | Living Reviews in Relativity
·
Gravitational waves signal analysis: Matched filtering, ...
·
time–frequency analysis of gravitational wave signals with non-harmonic analysis | Progress of Theoretical and Experimental Physics | Oxford Academic
·
Can you hear the (ultralow-frequency gravitational wave) music? | astrobites
·
Shuddha Saveri - Wikipedia
·
Shuddha Saveri
·
Karnataka Shuddha Saveri - Wikipedia
·
Raga Suddha Saveri : Raga Surabhi
·
Saveri - Wikipedia
·
Shuddha Saveri / Durga | Sai Rhythms
·
Mohanam & Shudha Saveri Ragams -
·
Raga - Eviolinguru
·
Chandraveena | Raga Durga - An Oriental Pentatonic
·
Saveri Ragam ( Raga Lakshanam ) – RAAGAMRUTA